Be everywhere the tools read
Get listed on the directories, review sites and local pages that each AI tool pulls from, not just one of them.
HVAC SEO asked ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Google Gemini to name the best HVAC company in 25 US and UK cities. In 0 of the 25 cities did all three name the same company, and some answers changed between asks.
A study by HVAC SEO, the local SEO and AI SEO company founded by Jacob Milner. October 2026. 125 answers recorded.
0 of 25cities where all three AI tools named the same company
4 of 25cities where ChatGPT and Gemini agreed on the top pick
11 of 25cities where ChatGPT changed its own answer between asks
346different companies named in total
64%of those companies were named only once
12 of 25cities where Google showed no AI Overview at all
Source: HVAC SEO, 25 cities, October 2026. One snapshot. AI answers change over time.
The HVAC AI Visibility Index found that AI search tools do not agree on the best HVAC company, and often do not agree with themselves. HVAC SEO asked each tool to name the best AC repair company in 20 US cities and the best boiler repair company in 5 UK cities.
In none of the 25 cities did ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Gemini all name the same top company.
ChatGPT and Gemini named the same top company in only 4 of 25 cities: Houston, Kansas City, Raleigh and Manchester.
Asked the same question three times, ChatGPT changed its own top pick in 11 of the 25 cities.
Across all answers, 346 different companies were named, and nearly two thirds of them appeared only once.
Google showed no AI Overview for the question in 12 of the 25 cities, so a direct three-way comparison was only possible in some markets.
The AI tools disagree because each one reads a different set of sources. A company that appears on the sites one tool trusts can be missing from the sites another tool trusts, so each tool builds a different shortlist.
| AI tool | Leaned on |
|---|---|
| ChatGPT | Expertise.com, ConsumerAffairs, ContractorsRanked, Birdeye. In the UK: Checkatrade, Which? Trusted Traders, MyBuilder. |
| Gemini | Forbes, Angi, ConsumerAffairs, HomeAdvisor, Best Pick Reports. |
| Google AI Overviews | Reddit, Yelp, Facebook. In the UK: Checkatrade, Trustatrader. |
Below is the top company each tool named in every city tested. Where ChatGPT gave a different answer across its three asks, the companies are listed in order. Company names are shown exactly as the AI tool wrote them.
| City | ChatGPT | Gemini | Google AI Overview |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phoenix | Day & Night Air Conditioning, Heating & Plumbing | Parker & Sons | Parker & Sons |
| Houston | Air Tech of Houston AC & Plumbing | Air Tech of Houston AC & Plumbing | Village Plumbing, Air & Electric |
| Dallas | Cody & Sons Plumbing, Heating & Air | Milestone Electric, A/C & Plumbing | No AI Overview |
| Austin | Infinity AC / Radiant / The Coolest (varied) | Grande Air Solutions | No AI Overview |
| San Antonio | Amazing Air Solutions | Murray Air Conditioning | Jon Wayne Service Company |
| Miami | TemPros / Direct Air Conditioning (varied) | Cool Breeze Air Conditioning | One Hour Heating & Air Conditioning of Miami |
| Tampa | Fontana Brothers Heating & Air Conditioning | The Comfort Authority | Air Masters of Tampa Bay |
| Orlando | Clear Comfort Air Conditioning & Heating | AmeriTech Air Conditioning & Heating | No AI Overview |
| Jacksonville | Donovan / Air McCall / Willman Air (varied) | Buehler Air Conditioning & Plumbing | No AI Overview |
| Atlanta | PV Heating & Air / O'Callaghan (varied) | Estes Services | No AI Overview |
| Las Vegas | Legacy Air / Bob's Repair (varied) | Elite Plumbing, Heating & Air Conditioning | Bob's Repair |
| Los Angeles | LC Heating & Air / Brody Pennell (varied) | Air Tech 24 Heating & Air Conditioning | Roku Air Conditioning and Heating |
| Denver | The Weather Changers | Save Home Heat Company | Roots Heating & Air |
| Chicago | Chicago HVAC Repair Doctor | Besco Air Heating & Cooling | No AI Overview |
| Kansas City | Buckner's Heating, Cooling & Plumbing | Buckner's Heating, Cooling & Plumbing | No AI Overview |
| New York | Airnizer HVAC / Weather Makers NYC (varied) | Figlia & Sons | Not returned |
| Charlotte | Horne / Morris-Jenkins (varied) | Acosta Heating, Cooling & Electrical | No AI Overview |
| Raleigh | Air Experts Heating & Cooling | Air Experts Heating & Cooling | No AI Overview |
| Nashville | Premier Heating & Air | Right Time HVAC | No AI Overview |
| Columbus | The Heating & Cooling Pro / Hetter / Custom Air (varied) | Hetter Heating & Cooling | No AI Overview |
| London (UK) | Boiler & Heating Care / Heat Knights (varied) | Silver Saints | Pimlico Plumbers |
| Manchester (UK) | A+R Central Heating | A&R Central Heating and Boiler Repair Experts | No AI Overview |
| Birmingham (UK) | Power Plus Heating / Birmingham Boiler Repairs (varied) | 2nd City Gas Plumbing & Heating | QuickFix Boiler Repair Services |
| Leeds (UK) | Secure Gas 247 | Safe Home Heating | iPlumb Leeds / Leeds Boiler Company |
| Bristol (UK) | The Gas Pro | Bristol Boiler Company | Core Heating |
"Varied" means ChatGPT named a different top company across its three asks in that city. "No AI Overview" means Google did not show an AI Overview for that search.
For an HVAC company, being named by AI is not about winning one ranking. Each tool reads a different set of sources, so a company has to be present and described the same way across all of them to be named consistently. A business that is strong on the sites ChatGPT reads can still be invisible to Google's AI Overviews.
Get listed on the directories, review sites and local pages that each AI tool pulls from, not just one of them.
Same name, services and service area on every source, so the tools are confident the same business is meant.
Real reviews and mentions on trusted sites are what move a company from named once to named often.
HVAC SEO asked each of three AI tools the same question for each city in October 2026, logged out and with no memory, so the answers match what a new user would see.
Cities: 20 US cities and 5 UK cities, 25 in total.
Question: for US cities, the best AC repair company; for UK cities, the best boiler repair company.
Tools: ChatGPT (asked three times per city), Google Gemini (once) and Google AI Overviews (once). 125 answers in total.
Limits: one snapshot in one month, at country level rather than a street address. AI answers change over time. The study reports only what the tools said and makes no claim about any company's quality.
No. In this 25-city test, ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews and Gemini never named the same top company in a single city. ChatGPT and Gemini matched on the top pick in only 4 of 25 cities.
No. Asked the same question three times in the same city, ChatGPT changed its own top pick in 11 of the 25 cities tested.
Each tool reads a different set of sources. ChatGPT leaned on directories like Expertise.com and ConsumerAffairs, Gemini on Forbes and Angi, and Google AI Overviews on Reddit, Yelp and Facebook. Different sources produce different shortlists.
Build consistent business details and genuine mentions across the sources each tool reads: directories, review sites, local pages and forums. Being described the same way everywhere is what makes a tool confident enough to name a business.
Jacob Milner will check your presence across ChatGPT, Gemini and Google AI for your services and towns, then email you a free one-page growth plan with the three fixes that matter most.